The $548 Mirror Look for $59.93
Anthropologie's Gleaming Primrose is the arched, gilded mirror half the internet is saving for — $548 for the 3-foot size. Walmart's Better Homes & Gardens Filigree Arch Mirror echoes it for $59.93, with glass reviewers consistently call thick and heavy for the price. The honest gap is scale: this is a vanity-and-mantel mirror, not a 39-inch statement.
| The Name: Anthropologie Gleaming Primrose Mirror, 3 ft | The Alternative: Better Homes & Gardens Filigree Arch Mirror | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $548 | $59.93 at Walmart |
| You save | — | $488 (89%) |
| Size | 39.25″ × 39″, ~31 lbs | 20″ × 30″, ~10 lbs — barely half the wall presence |
| Frame & detail | Handcrafted resin, iron and engineered hardwood; hand-finished ornament, side garlands | Iron frame with a distressed gold painted finish; stamped filigree detail |
| Owner signal | 1,000+ five-star reviews; owners call it a lifetime piece | 4.5 stars across ~1,800 ratings; thick glass praised, gold tone can vary by unit |
Prices checked by hand on October 23, 2026 at Walmart and Anthropologie; prices move with sales — confirm before you buy.
Our verdict: the alternative wins. You get the silhouette and genuinely thick glass for about $60. The catch is real, though: painted-metal detail instead of hand-cast ornament, at 20″ × 30″ against the Primrose's 39″ × 39″. If you need the big one to anchor a room, this isn't it — if you want the look over a vanity or mantel, it emphatically is.
Where the money goes
- The size: the Primrose 3-footer covers roughly two and a half times the wall area. The Filigree is closer in spirit to Anthropologie's smaller Primrose sizes — buy it for a vanity, entry or mantel, not as a room anchor.
- The ornament: the Primrose's relief is hand-cast resin and hardwood — deep, dimensional, with side garlands. The Filigree's scrollwork is formed in metal and painted gold; from across the room it reads the same, up close it doesn't.
- The glass: this is where Walmart didn't cheap out — owners and reviewers consistently note thick, heavy glass and a clean reflection, which is why 1,800 ratings average 4.5 stars. The recurring nit is gold tone that can look inconsistent on some units.
See the alternative at Walmart See the original at Anthropologie
Dopperly may earn a commission from purchases made through links on this page, at no cost to you. Full disclosure. We are never paid to change a verdict.